Israel right to exist
Tuesday, May 6th, 2008Abraham - Isaac - God
Two Jewish rabbis yesterday called for a peaceful end of Israel saying that the existence of the “Israeli state” was contradictory to the Jewish law.
This what a Newsvine.com Jewish rabbis call for dismantling Israel article says, dated Fri May 2, 2008.
My comments were deleted by the author of the article Dennis P. McCann so I am creating this post with my comments.
A user asked if the Rabbis are legitimate and does Israel have a right to exist!
First of all I did not make these two people Rabbis, so how can I vouch for their legitimacy? I also do not know how one becomes a Rabbi because I am not a Rabbi. Is a Rabbi appointed by the congregation, by another Rabbi, or self appointed? Moses taught God’s Law to the Hebrews, was he a Rabbi or was he a man of God? There is one tribe the Levi of Israel that is suppose to guard the Holly scriptures - the Torah, the Talmud, and other scrolls. Are these Rabbi of the Levi?
Moses is a Levi but did he get the Hebrew Law from a book or from God? Moses is a descendant of Levi. In the Hebrew Bible it says that Levi are the keepers of the Holly scriptures. Jacob - Israel is the father of Levi. Jacob is the descendant of Abraham.
So both Abraham and Jacob are not Levi but they spoke with God and passed God’s words to their descendants. Jewish people are children of Israel. I presume the Rabbis are Jewish! LOL How are they interpreting God’s Law I do not know.
The land of Israel was given to Abraham by God in a covenant between Abraham and God. So if you question Israel existence you need to talk to God.
Now for the State of Israel which was created bu U.N. So if you have a question about that talk to U.N.
Zionist believe in the creation of the State of Israel and believe that all Jews should go back to live in the State of Israel, although modern Zionist have different views on this as well. I am not a Zionist so I cannot speak on their behalf. Is to be Jewish one has to be a Zionist? No! And thank God for that, otherwise there may not be any Jewish people left alive today.
Judaism is a religion and one can live any place they wish and still be Jewish. Jewish people are of Hebrew origin. Abraham and Jacob are Hebrews. Jewish name comes from the tribe of Judah, which is one of the tribes of Israel. Are Jewish people - race descendants of Abraham the Hebrew? Yes.
Should have the State of Israel have been created? The U.N. has decided that Jewish people should have a country of their own. I as a Jewish person do not really care where I live. I do care about having a passport because I need one, and it is an Israeli passport.
If tomorrow U.N will call some over land the State of Israel will I be able to do anything about that? Maybe it will be the Japanese island of Kyushu, or the American Island of Manhattan, or even Thai island of Koh Pangan?
What ever the land location that would be called the State of Israel that would be the State of Israel, and I would have a passport from the State of Israel. To me Israel is a believe not a piece of land, but to other Jewish people it may be different.
Should the State of Israel have been created in the first place? Yes it should have. Every people need a country. Was the location appropriately chosen by U.N.? Well should U.N. have chosen Berlin, Saint Petersburg, or maybe even Hollywood? So as you can see, based on the Bible the location was chosen appropriately.
If you would like a different location for the State of Israel, please talk to the U.N., not me!
This was the long answer. Here comes the short answer.
Does Israel have a right to exist? Yes. Does the State of Israel has a right to exist? Yes. Do Jewish people have a right to exist? Yes.
Anymore questions regarding Israel, the State of Israel, Jewish people, Judaism, or the Hebrews you are more than welcome to address them to me, and I will try to answer them to the best of my ability.
